So I accepted the challenge and ordered Wool of the Andes in baltic, cilantro, grizzly, and marble heathers, along with clarity. I added some stashed yellow to assuage any yarn accumulation guilt and I was ready to go.
I wanted the cropped version but I have long arms and a long torso (think monkey) and, after swatching, knew the ribbing wouldn't hit me in the right place. Since my row count was a little bit off, I thought I could knit the full length version and still, possibly, get the slightly shrunken look.
So I knit the long version in the smallest size and I'm satisfied with the fit. It's not too fitted but I can wear it with my low waisted jeans, which I will desperately need after holiday eating.
The entire time I worked on this I kept thinking how classic it felt. The chart and the pattern itself. I felt like I was making something vintage and using techniques my great grandmother would have employed if she had knit rather than sewn. That's a good, grounded feeling to have about your making.
No, my difficulties came from my own tired brain. I knit at night and don't always read carefully or think things through. After working the body flat, I just started working the sleeves in the round. I have no idea why I didn't do them flat. It would have been easier. I also think my stitch count was wrong on one shoulder. Thankfully, my gauge was the same on sleeve and body (Sometimes working fair isle in the round makes it tighter than when flat.) Most likely, they would have been easier for me to set the sleeves in had I worked them flat. Since I didn't, the seaming really kicked me.
I could not get my shoulders to look right. I tried everything. I frayed two different seaming strands of yarn from all of the seaming, then ripping. My sleeve cap seemed to be too tall for the body and seaming it resulted in an extreme puffy shoulder that inched ever- upward, like it had been hung on the most misshaped wire coat hanger in existence. I've included a frustrated phone pic of it, below. It didn't look forties; it looked like a factory mistake. Or a birth defect.
I had done something wrong.
I tried a gathering technique I saw on By Gum By Golly, in which I ran a thread through the cap and gathered it before using mattress stitch to seam it. Even so, it seemed that my sleeve just wasn't the right width or height for the top of the body. So I had to modify.
My mods, some of which you will be too wise to need:
I used size 2 needles and reduced the cast on stitches for the body ribbing by 12 because my ribbing is always too loose. I just increased by 12 with the first even knit row in color A.
For the shoulder fix, I undid my sleeve seams enough to free up the top of the sleeve cap on each side. Then I ripped back just the top of it. I started re-knitting it about 34 rows after the second underarm bind off. (I happened to be on row 3 of the color chart.) I decreased on the purl side once and did the K2tog, repeat row sooner so my sleeve caps came out a little shorter and less pointed. It wasn't a big difference, but I think it compensated for whatever mistake I made in the knitting.
For the button loop, I just picked up 3 little stitches from the top corner of the right side of the neckband and knit a few rows of I-cord, then curved it downward to the place where I wanted to attach the loop. I picked up three more stitches from that area and joined the I-cord with it using Kitchener stitch. I like it and it feels sturdy.
This pattern was well written and thought out, so much so that I am positive the difficulty in seaming was due to my own knitting mistakes. I haven't had a lot of experience seaming sweaters (I've only made a few that weren't seamless.) so I thought the pattern instructions for pressing the individual pieces before seaming was a nice touch. There is also an option to gather the front and back of the top a little, like the longer sample knit. I really like that look too.
I'm also left with a desire to knit more from Rohn Strong. I'm thinking Betty... Betty Grable would be great for a Downton Abbey KAL, should there be one, when worn lace side up. It has a similar collar to a few jackets I've seen on the show. I think it would help me break into crochet. I also love the ease and casual look of Brando. His designer's page is here.
I've written about this a lot because it's been on my needles since before all of the Christmas knitting. Should you be interested, there's:
color combo and ribbing,
picking or throwing,